World Soccer forums >> The Big Issue

 |  Print Thread
badgerboy
member


Reged: 26/03/2007
Posts: 727
Loc: Bucks, England
Re: The Big Issue 14: Extra referees / linesmen?
      02/04/2008 12:38

I'm a big fan of Platini on most things.

But this isn't one of them.

Goal-line technology itself makes sense - although I'm not even convinced that has to be as "technical" as people make out. Appropriately stationed TV cameras & the general rule that - "if studying the replay for a limited amount of time doesn't clearly show the ball is over the line, then it isn't a goal" makes sense.

Indeed - instead of introducing extra officials - why not just give more power to the fourth official. Allow him (rather than forbid him) to use TV monitors to review close decisions & ensure he is in constant communication with the actual referee.

I also don't hold with the argument that: "it's wrong to introduce technology into top level football because it should be the same as park football". Why?

Just because they have hawkeye at Wimbledon doesn't mean they have access to it at all tennis clubs around the country. Even at Wimbledon the technology is only available on the show courts (I think!) and I'm 100% sure nothing of the sort is available in the qualifiers. That doesn't make it a "different game" it just gives the top games the opportunity to be fairer.

Post Extras Print Post   Remind Me!     Notify Moderator



Entire topic
Subject Posted by Posted on
* The Big Issue 14: Extra referees / linesmen? Rogorn 14/03/2008 18:40
. * * Re: The Big Issue 14: Extra referees / linesmen? washiefrog   22/06/2008 10:39
. * * Re: The Big Issue 14: Extra referees / linesmen? footballisfixed   01/08/2008 07:41
. * * Re: The Big Issue 14: Extra referees / linesmen? worldsoccerAdministrator   17/03/2008 17:05
. * * Re: The Big Issue 14: Extra referees / linesmen? MKMark   10/06/2008 13:53
. * * Re: The Big Issue 14: Extra referees / linesmen? squidge   01/04/2008 17:56
. * * Re: The Big Issue 14: Extra referees / linesmen? badgerboy   02/04/2008 12:38
. * * Re: The Big Issue 14: Extra referees / linesmen? AndyNeill   03/04/2008 19:53
. * * Re: The Big Issue 14: Extra referees / linesmen? subhankar_mondal   11/05/2008 07:07
. * * Re: The Big Issue 14: Extra referees / linesmen? Rogorn   11/05/2008 09:10
. * * Re: The Big Issue 14: Extra referees / linesmen? AndyNeill   23/05/2008 10:57
. * * Re: The Big Issue 14: Extra referees / linesmen? ranckoner   02/06/2008 09:17
. * * Re: The Big Issue 14: Extra referees / linesmen? AndyNeill   05/06/2008 17:51
. * * Re: The Big Issue 14: Extra referees / linesmen? Rogorn   05/06/2008 21:27
. * * Re: The Big Issue 14: Extra referees / linesmen? barney   18/03/2008 15:26
. * * Re: The Big Issue 14: Extra referees / linesmen? stephen_woodside   18/03/2008 23:06
. * * Re: The Big Issue 14: Extra referees / linesmen? Rogorn   22/03/2008 18:12

Extra information
0 registered and 3 anonymous users are browsing this forum.

Moderator:   


Print Thread
Forum Permissions
      You cannot start new topics
      You cannot reply to topics
      HTML is disabled
      Mark-up is enabled

Rating:
Thread views: 8776

Rate this thread

Jump to
Contact Us | Privacy statement World Soccer homepage