World Soccer forums >> Football - General

 |  Print Thread
RichieC
member


Reged: 17/07/2006
Posts: 535
Six plus Five
      02/06/2008 09:58

One thing that strikes me about FIFA's Six plue Five idea (whereby a team would have to field no more than 5 'foreign nationals') is...while everyone is clamouring about it being illegal in the EU as being a restraint of trade, surely that only applies to the actual employment of said players. A club could still employ as many 'foreigners' as they like, but would them being left out of the team on a saturday be regarded as a restraint of trade as no one has stopped them being employed (though they are in effect being stopped from applying their trade in the workplace). Surely this could, in theory, allow a player to claim 'restraint of trade' if the coach doesn't pick him on a saturday at the moment? The original Bosman case was brought because the club he played for refused to let him leave, which was indeed a restraint of trade as it stopped him from being employed...The six plus five rule wouldn't stop anyone being employed at all...

Post Extras Print Post   Remind Me!     Notify Moderator



Entire topic
Subject Posted by Posted on
* Six plus Five RichieC 02/06/2008 09:58
. * * Re: Six plus Five stephen_woodside   02/06/2008 12:21
. * * Re: Six plus Five badgerboy   02/06/2008 15:51
. * * Re: Six plus Five RichieC   02/06/2008 16:32
. * * Re: Six plus Five henryfan1   03/06/2008 12:54
. * * Re: Six plus Five RichieC   03/06/2008 14:16
. * * Re: Six plus Five ubeep   09/07/2008 08:53
. * * Re: Six plus Five Rogorn   09/07/2008 09:48
. * * Re: Six plus Five ubeep   09/07/2008 11:08
. * * Re: Six plus Five Rogorn   09/07/2008 13:29
. * * Re: Six plus Five ubeep   09/07/2008 15:16
. * * Re: Six plus Five Rogorn   09/07/2008 18:11
. * * Re: Six plus Five RichieC   10/07/2008 13:23
. * * Re: Six plus Five badgerboy   12/07/2008 15:53

Extra information
1 registered and 14 anonymous users are browsing this forum.

Moderator:  worldsoccer 


Print Thread
Forum Permissions
      You cannot start new topics
      You cannot reply to topics
      HTML is disabled
      Mark-up is enabled

Rating:
Thread views: 2379

Rate this thread

Jump to
Contact Us | Privacy statement World Soccer homepage